Image Credit: https://d1c1jxr970h1ka.cloudfront.net/public/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/06133129/Facility_10_r_p.png

Geolocating Explosive Growth in Preschools in Western China due to ‘re-education’ Policies

Authors from RAND: Katherine Pfrommer, and Ed Burke
Latest
Part 1
20 child facilities identified
Impact
geolocating human rights issues
Updated
APR 16
78 Days Ago

Overview

Twenty facilities that imagery analysis, press and professional journals suggest house Uyghur children have been identified in this first study of geolocating China's detention infrastructure targeting Uyghurs and other Muslim minority groups.

This methodology report can help other researchers identify these child detention facilities (mostly from satellite imagery). Other researchers can view this analysis in 3rd-party tools such as Google Earth or ESRI systems. Structured data (Excel and CSV) is also available for download for 3rd-party enhancements or study.


Activity

GEOINT analysis shows steady construction progress at probable Chinese preschool facilities in southern Xinjiang.

Last Major Revision on:

China's detention since 2017 of more than one million ethnic Turkic Muslim adults in its northwestern province of Xinjiang has been widely reported and accepted at face value as a matter of US policy, but the fate of the children separated from their parents as a result of these policies has received less coverage. Chinese official press has said the transformation through education facilities for adults teach Chinese language and values, while Western researchers and nongovernmental organizations liken the facilities to internment camps, where the detained adults are subjected to forced indoctrination. The mass removal of parents and other adult extended family members from their homes has resulted in a need to house children. Satellite imagery-based research confirms that construction of new, suspected preschool facilities, which appear to serve the dual purpose of housing and educating children, coincided with the adult detention program, probably to meet the increased childcare needs necessitated by the governments wide-ranging crackdown and core policy of ethnic unity. For its part, China characterizes the construction of both preschools and boarding schools in Xinjiang as part of its poverty alleviation efforts.

Against this backdrop, RAND researchers, using NGA-funded commercial imagery and methodology reviews, sought to add to the body of research available by performing a satellite imagery search to find examples of suspected preschool facilities. The imagery search was restricted to rural areas the Uyghur-majority city of Hotan because new construction would stand out more there than in urban environments. As of July and August 2018, Chinese procurement officials sought to build at least nine structures with enough beds to house about 5,000 children in and around Hotan. Most facilities reportedly include a minimum of 100 beds, with some accommodating much larger capacities. The goal was to identify some of these facilities, characterize them in a narrative and then provide geolocated and structured data of the suspect facilities as foundational data for subsequent research. This work is exploratory, and therefore qualitative; it is intended to be iterative.

To date, RAND, using NGA-funded commercial imagery, has identified 20 suspect facilities that meet our imagery-based identification criteria, which is informed by other research and reporting. Broadly, the 20 facilities have similar construction timelines, locations, and physical features.

  • A majority of the identified facilities were constructed since 2016, which is consistent with the timing cited by other researchers. Their construction coincided with the construction of additional detention facilities, according to Western researchers and media.
  • Many of the structures stand on what was open land or modest homes prior to construction of the multistory structures. Nearly all of the identified newly constructed facilities are in villages on Hotans periphery; this is a result of our methodology, which concentrated the search in these areas.
  • Physical features. Most of the buildings we identified are approximately 35 meters long by 20 meters wide, while some are only 15 meters wide. They are typically either two or three stories tall, and often brightly colored with ornamental architectural features like castle towers. In some instances, two identical buildings were built on the same lot. Some of the other features that serve as imagery signatures for these facilities include: multiple, sometimes colorful circles that appear to support outdoor play by young children; playground equipment sets; and high walls with only a single security-controlled entry point. There is often another, smaller structure next to the main building which was completed on the same timeline. While a definitive purpose for the smaller structure is unknown, one potential purpose is that it houses security and other administrative staff, as the facility likely is staffed around the clock.

This research does not represent a comprehensive imagery search of all of Xinjiang, which at 660,000 square miles in area is about four times the size of the state of California. Xinjiang authorities in early 2017 reportedly had begun the construction of 4,387 preschools to accommodate 562,900 new students, so this research has identified just a very small percentage of the potential total, and just in rural areas near Hotan. Figures 1-4 below and imagery in the timeline section represent examples of the distinctive features present in newly constructed preschool buildings.

Figure 1: Example of paired preschool buildings completed near Hotan since 2017

Facility_11_dg_r

Figure 2: Example of preschool with colorful mat/circle characteristic completed near Hotan since 2017

Facility_10_r_p

Figure 3: Example of mats/circles with different characteristics

Facility_8_dg_r

Figure 4: Example of ornamental tower near access control point

Facility_4_dg_r

19 Nov 2019
Facility #12 - colorful circles (finished)
Distinct colorful circles (play mats) characteristic. Researchers can apply the satellite imagery characteristics methodology of preschools within tools like Google Earth.

Source(s): Google Earth Historical Layers
26 Feb 2019
Facility #1 - ornamental towers with playground (finished)
Distinct ornamental towers on buildings and near access control point characteristic.

Source(s): Google Earth Historical Layers
2 Oct 2017
Facility #12 - under construction
Follows general construction pattern from mid-2017.

Source(s): Google Earth Historical Layers
14 Aug 2017
Facility #1 - under construction
Follows general construction pattern from mid-2017.

Source(s): Google Earth Historical Layers
25 Feb 2016
Facility #1 - No construction yet
Open field 2016.

Source(s): Google Earth Historical Layers
3 Jul 2015
Facility #12 - No construction yet
Open field 2015.

Source(s): Google Earth Historical Layers

Hotan Facilities

Google Earth (KML/KMZ) view of Hotan facilities.

Looking Ahead

This is the first report in a series of geolocation studies to document comprehensively China's detention infrastructure targeting Uyghurs and other Muslim minority groups. Please see "Data Sources" section for other download formats to help with methodology familiarization.

Things To Watch

  • ground clearing in rural areas
  • ornamental towers near entry access points
  • ornamental towers on top of multi-story buildings
  • colorful mats and circles
  • part 2 of geolocation series coming soon...

Data Sources

kml Hotan Preschool Facility Annotations
shp Hotan Preschool Facility Annotations
excel Hotan Preschool Facilities Structured Data
csv Hotan Preschool Facilities Structured Data

About the Authors

Katherine Pfrommer
Katherine Pfrommer

Quantitative Analyst, RAND

Ed Burke
Ed Burke

Senior Advisor, RAND

Tearline
National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency

Methodologies Reviewed by NGA